East Hampton School Cuts From July That Haven't Come Back
A third-grade teacher, a high school English teacher, the math tutor and the rest of the July cut list have not been restored. Smart Start, four middle school sports and the high school's preschool program are back for this school year only.
Most of the school cuts East Hampton's superintendent laid out in July have not been restored in any board meeting or district report since, among them a third-grade teacher, a high school English teacher, the high school math tutor, full-time art at Center School and one of the two buses that take students to vocational programs out of town.
Parts of the list did come back, but only for this school year. A state grant brought Smart Start preschool back, donors are paying for middle school soccer, cross-country, cheerleading and volleyball, and the Lions Club is paying the stipend for the high school's preschool program. The district has already begun work on next year's budget.
Superintendent Dr. Timothy Van Tasel presented the list to the Board of Education on Wednesday, July 15, at a special meeting the day after voters turned down the school budget for a second time. "Unfortunately, it is loss of programs," he said.
What was on the July list
The cuts were meant to bring the budget about $600,000 below the one voters turned down in June: the $250,000 already cut after that vote, plus about $350,000 more. The board took no vote on the list. The proposed reductions were:
- Memorial School's assistant principal, from a 12-month to a 10-month job
- The Smart Start preschool program
- A third-grade classroom teacher, which Van Tasel said would leave third-grade classes at 23 to 25 children
- A special education paraeducator, a classroom aide in a specialized program, after a student who needed one-to-one support left the district
- Center School's art teacher, cut by 0.4 of a position to part time. "This could result in an art teacher perhaps leaving this district that is beloved," Van Tasel said.
- A special education interventionist, a trained support worker, not a paraeducator, who works one-on-one with students who need extra support
- Middle school athletics
- A high school English language arts teacher, in place of the science teacher on an earlier list
- The high school math tutor
- A high school family and consumer science course, tied to the high school's preschool program
- One of the two buses that carry about 34 students to out-of-town vocational agriculture and Vinal Technical High School programs
- Digital subscriptions, after-school clubs, facilities spending and savings from staff turnover
Board Chair Nancy Kohler listed what the schools had given up a year earlier, including high school social studies, world language and math teachers, the middle school's library media specialist and two elementary teachers.
Smart Start drew the most public comment. Shelby Galvin, whose child had been accepted into the program, said the state had confirmed a grant of $97,500 for the year. "If the district declines nearly $100,000 in state funding, what are the actual net savings to the taxpayers?" she asked. Van Tasel put the cost of running it at about $226,000 and said what was left after the grant and family fees was more than the district could carry. "Is it required? It's not required by the state," he said. "Is it beneficial? 100%."
Back for one year
On Thursday, Aug. 6, the board unanimously accepted an additional one-year grant of up to $73,500 from the state Office of Early Childhood, on top of the program's existing state grant, and Smart Start reopened. The same night it accepted an offer from the East Hampton Soccer Club to cover the cost of middle school boys' and girls' soccer this school year. By Aug. 17, sponsors had been found for cross-country, cheerleading and volleyball, the board's minutes say.
A third budget vote failed Aug. 5. When the Board of Finance recommended a $39,550,937 budget for a fourth referendum on Aug. 10, its minutes noted that Smart Start and middle school sports were back "although only for this year." The Town Council sent it to voters, 6-1, on Aug. 11, and voters passed it Aug. 26.
On Sept. 28 the board accepted an $8,000 gift from the East Hampton Lions Club that pays the stipend for the high school's preschool program this school year.
Not every sport returned. On Oct. 26, Van Tasel told the board the district could not get middle school basketball going this winter because of its cost and the number of players paying to participate. Parks and Recreation will have basketball, and it is finalizing an after-school basketball clinic. Parents and the middle school PTO are still raising money for baseball and softball.
What hasn't come back
At the Aug. 10 Board of Finance meeting, Van Tasel said the district was going ahead with its plan for the $600,000 cut. High School Principal Eric Verner told the board Oct. 5 that the math tutor position was cut.
The bus cut is in place. On July 15 the board changed its transportation policy so that walking-distance limits do not apply to central pickup spots for vocational students. Students who had been picked up near home now meet the bus at one of several central stops. Van Tasel said Sept. 14 that families had written about the change. The district had checked with its lawyer and will not go back to door-to-door service, the minutes say.
The third-grade and high school English positions, and the rest of the list, have not been restored in any board record since.
Next year's budget
At an Aug. 17 meeting, board members broadly supported putting the middle school sports back in next year's budget rather than relying on fundraising, and the administration called private money a temporary bridge, according to the minutes.
On July 15, during public comment, Cristal Chan, now the board's newest member, suggested that the district look at consolidating Center School, moving its fourth and fifth grades into the other schools, to save money over the long run. "That is a very difficult conversation to have," Van Tasel said.